NYS Coyote Hunters

For all you western NYers I stopped by the new shop in Bloomfield NY last night to see what it is all about and they had the foxpro FX3 cheeper than I have seen it on the net. He must not be moving them because he told me to tell my buddies that he would make them a deal if they come in. I told him I would let you guys know so tell him that you got the info from Mike. I was a huge shop with all kinds of guns/bows/calls and a heck of an archery range. Just thought I would pass the word because it is nice to have a shop around again.

Mike
 
Quote:
. I guess it wouldn't convince you to show you pictures or give you names of landowners where I've killed many greys over the years. After all, you so much as called me a liar when I said I just killed 2 greys in the same night very near the skating rink...lol, I wouldn't give you names anyway /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif



Hickerx2,Any pics yet /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/confused1.gif /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smiliesmack.gif
 
hicherX2,

No you didn't insult me, I took no offense to what you said or claimed, I never inferred you were a liar at anytime (that's not me), nor did I ever insinuate that there were no grey fox in this area.

Quote:
After all, you so much as called me a liar when I said I just killed 2 greys in the same night very near the skating rink...lol, I wouldn't give you names anyway



Never said that hicker......

Quote:
Yeah, I do know where the skating rink is....I live 1/2 mile from it, and I've never seen a grey anywhere nearby. Not strolling in the fields, not gnawing on a deer carcass, and definitely not coming in to a call. And that's putting in some heavy hunting over the past 17yrs. in just this area alone, not to mention many others I've hunted.



.....and as far as names, I already know everyone. Bruce VanSlyke still owns the rink as far as I know (it's been up for sale many times over the years).
Depending on "where" you hunted near the rink, most of the property around it within several hundred yards is either posted, or illegal to hunt, as all but a small portion of it is too close to existing residences. The village limits run very close to the rink, and square off only a short distance behind it.
There are spots owned by a local farmer (Danny Albro) where "I assume" you might've been hunting at, and I've been friends with Danny for just about ever. I've hunted his land steadily for the whole time I've lived here, and have never seen a grey.
The only other big landowners in this area are Tommy Ayers and Greg & Gary VanSlyke, and I have explicit permission to hunt their properties at anytime. Your talking literally thousands of acres combined in this surrounding area where I've hunted and based on those experiences, and the time involved, I made my observations known.

Just because I didn't see the same thing that you were claiming, at no time did I say that you were lying, or even inscinuated it. I just stated clearly that "I haven't seen it", and that's after putting in the time hunting.
My statement never mentioned, "you never did", "you couldn't have", or, "in no way" you had gotten a grey.

I gave you your due, and didn't dispute your experiences over here regarding grey's, but clearly, I basically stated that my observations and results haven't matched yours.
Not an argument, even though you may feel it's argumentative, it's not.....more a statement based on what I've experienced.

I do feel that the fact that I've lived and hunted heavily here for the past 17yrs. should hold some merit, regarding sightings, and/or frequency of such.

Quote:
I'm betting that if you're calling that high a ratio of reds, you're not hunting in the right spots for greys. Generally speaking, they come from totally different areas. It seems very odd to me that anybody could do any amount of calling without calling an occasional grey fox.



Other than sparse pockets of grey populations, where are "the right spots" ?
As far as doing "any amount of calling" and not seeing a grey respond, yes that is odd, unless there are none to be called in that specific area.
Grey's and reds don't discern any differences in calling, and where one will come to a given call, so will the other, if the populations are there.
As far as one spot being more productive for greys over red's, with no previous knowledge of population levels, and knowing exactly where that would be based on "geographical visual queue's", you'd be a better man than me at it if you can make that assessment based on those factors.
I'm sure it has more to do with population and "earshot", rather than geography.

Grey's do have a tendency to hold closer to brush and wooded area's more than red's, but I hunt those areas more than half of the time anyway.

Quote:
I was just looking to strike up a conversation with somebody that hunts in the same areas as I do.



Very glad to do so hicker, and I sincerely appreciate the fact that you live nearby and we hunt the same areas. But because I don't agree with you on a given issue, (respectfully mind you), does that mean that I'm trying to flame you, or call you a liar....not in any way.
You made the statement, or claim, and I never said, or inferred you were a liar. Just that my results didn't indicate even a moderate population of greys around here.

No offense intended......feel free to post any photo's that show some type of recognizable landmark I can attest to, and I'll gladly and freely admit here that it was in fact, taken at that location. I know the area very well and will gladly locate the spot if need be.



Take care,
Bob
 
Well,

Based on my statement of "not seeing any greys"....maybe someone "up there" read my post.....
I do believe that I had a grey respond to my call last night.
After Dennis and I hunted a couple of stands in one area, and seeing nothing, we started towards another area, and when close to the location where we were headed, he scanned a field with the handheld spot.
Seeing eyes along a diversion ditch, I stopped. It was obviously a fox, and due to the vehicle lights, it headed for the hedge. After pulling the truck up and quickly (but quietly) unloading our gear, we setup at the closer corner of the field, and I started calling. (Bullet call, Mark)

I was able to call that same fox back down the ditch to within 100-125yds, where it popped up over the edge into the corn stubble. I was on it with the .22-250 and had my objective set too far out, causing it to appear blurry somewhat. I went to make a quick adjustment, and Dennis seeing that, started to drop the light directly down onto the fox to light it directly for me to shoot. Just prior to the shot, it dropped back down into the ditch, only a couple feet away.
What I did see of the fox, even though slightly blurry, it appeared very much to be a grey. I've seen many red's lit up at night, and this one had a far more darker greyish tone and a shorter, pointier muzzle. There was two other fox around 300-400yds out farther, and they headed into some brush when the other fox got near them.
I wouldn't take a snap shot, and I don't feel badly about it never the less.
Just happy to believe that I saw one.
This area was located near the Perry/Covington line on the north end of our county, probably 20-25 miles from home.

Maybe, with luck, I can get even with Andy, and make it a first at the same time....LOL

Take care gang,
Bob
 
Just for my FYI and others, but I think I've read where grays and reds don't socialize. Any one know if this is true or not? (This doesn't make sense to me, if true.)
 
Double wow....

I guess I've tromped on some egos inadvertently. I'm very sorry for that. I've never set foot in Tioga County(not sure why you call it "western" NY), so I have no relevant comments about your grey fox. As for pics, I don't take daily pics of the fox I kill, although I have pics around of my lots at the various auctions and some shots showing season totals from some years back. In any event, you, who I've never spoken to, nor directed any comments at, feel the need to imply that I'm lying....wow

I will tell you in no uncertain terms that there is a healthy population of grey fox in Wyoming county. The quotes from Handgunr alone tell volumes(emphasis mine):

"I realize that the red's and grey's inhabit the same area's and that they'll readily respond to the same calls."

Not even close. Wyoming Co. is generally flat with large fields, open farmland, and lots of small woodlots. You will not call grey fox in the same areas you call reds in.

"Knowing fox like I do, virtually it's a flip of the coin as to which variety will respond if both grey's & red's inhabit the same area. One reason why I know their numbers are very short over here."

Again, not even close. Methinks somebody has too high an opinion of their knowledge of fox. Successfully calling grey fox takes some specialized tactics in areas that are so "red fox friendly"

"I've never seen a grey anywhere nearby. Not strolling in the fields, not gnawing on a deer carcass, and definitely not coming in to a call."

Again....grey fox do not "stroll" in open fields and they're primary diet consists of fruit, berries, and insects,(they love frogs and snakes though) which is why they respond so well to pup distress sounds, very unlike the red fox. Grey fox are much more seclusive than reds, largely due to their diminutive size and their lower position on the food chain. God did not give grey fox sharp cat-like claws for "strolling in fields and mousing. They have them for climbing trees to get apples and such and to escape predators.

"I can take you right to many fox den's locally, and not knowing what variety is living in them at that time, put you in a guaranteed spot where you'll get one, but I'd bet based on my experience in this area, it'll be a red 99% of the time."

With such a vast knowledge of fox, it should be quite simple to determine what's living in the den. A red fox den will have alot of bones and hair-filled scat. A grey fox den will have very few bones, if any, and scat will be mostly black with alot of seeds. BTW, fox don't den at any time of the year except durin the mating /rearing season. You may see one take shelter in a hole occasionally, but that's not a den. I am curious about these "guaranteed" spots though...lol

In any event, I have nothing to prove, Nor do you (whoever you are), nor does Handgunr. I was simply trying to conversate with people with a love for fox hunting like I have. I'm sorry for injuring your egos and I could really care less whether anybody believes a word I say. I guess I'm rather lucky in that regard and I hope that every fox hunter in Wyoming Co. feels the same way you guys do. I will never have to worry about the grey fox being over-hunted there like they are here where 90% of the hunters kill predominently greys(because they're easy to hunt). I love the fact that I only have to drive 30 miles to hunt grey fox that the locals believe are non-existent.

I don't care at all what type of hunting you or anybody else enjoys. It sounds like Handgunr is pretty good at hunting red fox. I guess I could be closed-minded as well and say that there's no way that red fox respond as eagerly as he claims( here, in the last 15 yrs or so, they respond very cautiously, often circling downwind), but then I'd be like you guys....so I won't say it.

I never was much for pissing matches so .....I wish you good luck in your fox hunting.
 
Quote:
Just for my FYI and others, but I think I've read where grays and reds don't socialize. Any one know if this is true or not? (This doesn't make sense to me, if true.)



That is absolutely true. Reds and greys are utterly and distinctly different animals. There will always be some degree of habitat overlap but for the most part, they do not share food sources, habitat, or habits with red fox.

In some areas of the country(ie; Texas) they can both be found in the same habitat, mostly because there are not different sub-habitats to separate them. They can and do co-exist with red fox quite nicely as there is no competition between the two. Grey fox, unlike reds can also co-exist with coyotes for the same reasons. Coyotes and red fox compete for the same food and habitat, which is why they are "enemies".

I hold a B.S. degree in Fisheries and Wildlife Biology and have been with the NYSDEC for 11 yrs. I've always had a special interest in fox and am glad to answer any questions that I can.
 
I don't care for the bickering, but did enjoy all the knowledge given out. I just love hunting both of the little critters. Get out and get some boys, more fun shooting than discussing it. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/ooo.gif
 
Here comes WOW # 3.....

Now you're being insulting hicker.......
Not only to me, but to others here that don't agree with you. That's just plain rude, and this thread has done very well without that kind of garbage.

So here goes.....

If you want to make wild claims, and think that everyone will take your word for it, or should, just because you said so, then you must feel you're talking to other's whom you believe to be ignorant, which isn't very realistic or smart.
You have to remember that there's always someone out there (not necessarily me) that knows a little more, or knows a given area, a little better than you do.
And if you're openly disputed, then you offer proof (which you openly did), then you need to put up, or shut up. You offered photo's and proof, then backed away from both when called upon by sureshot56 and myself.....?????
Again you offered the proof, and when called on it, you got insulting.

Now my turn......

As far as 50+ grey's in one season around here, even trapping them, based on my local experience, I highly doubt it. If you want to make open slams at people's hunting styles, or lack of knowledge, then you're being rude and disrespectful of others.
By the way, anytime you'd like to pit your "superior skills and knowledge" against mine, I'll be more than willing to help you put your foot in your mouth.

Also, geographically, Wyoming Co. is far from "generally flat". Illinois and Indiana are generally flat, been there... There's lots of farmland in Wyoming Co., yes, but it's greatly rolling farmland, and far from what I'd call flat. The flattest part of the county is along the "Gainesville Flats" between Gainesville & Hermitage where it is the flattest area for the longest span of distance.
Woodlots in Wyoming, although there are some small ones, the majority aren't small.
And since you said you hunted Wethersfield, I guess you'd call that flat too, but since they put the new wind farm at that point, the highest point in the county, I guess they made a mistake huh ?
But considering your description of this county, and your vast knowledge of it, I guess my years as a Deputy patrolling it don't matter.


Quote:
Again....grey fox do not "stroll" in open fields and they're primary diet consists of fruit, berries, and insects,(they love frogs and snakes though) which is why they respond so well to pup distress sounds, very unlike the red fox.




Okay, they "tip toe" in open fields, how's that ? You mean to tell me that they never enter an open area....man, that's far fetched.

As far as differing diets, like I mentioned before, (since your examining fecal matter so much) all fox are creatures of opportunity, and will eating anything considered edible to them. Red's eat frogs and snakes as well......other than a possible difference in shape, scat contents aren't always a particularly good determining factor of species based on their "overall diet".

Also, what happens to your "grey fox diet theory" once the majority of the fruit & berry crop is greatly diminished from deer, birds, frost & snow, the frogs and snakes go into hibernation, and not to mention all of the insects around in the middle of winter ????????
Boy what do they have to eat now ? And usually the worst time of the year as well ? Hmmmmm, ponder that.

It'd be like trying to figure out which branch of the human race crapped on your front lawn based on whether they ate at Pizza Hut, or McDonalds.
C'mon man, go back to reading your wildlife books.....

Oh yeah, regarding den's and this time of year, geeze, you apparently missed the point entirely....
Quote:
BTW, fox don't den at any time of the year except durin the mating /rearing season.



What time of year is it now ?
Maybe a tad early, but they're paired up already. Could that mean that maybe they have den's already chosen, or should I tell them that you said it was too early yet ?

Oh, by the way, my "red fox claims" are backed up by "photos" and a story of the hunt......check back a ways in the posts you'll see it.

You brought the "pissing match" upon yourself....


Bob
 
A pic of a red fox is proof of what?

Wild claims?

My "wild claim" was that there are grey fox in wyoming county.....which you immediately disputed based upon your intimate knowledge of foxes.

Look, you're the one that called me a liar from the start...obviously overcompensating for something since there is no point in disputing the mere presence of grey fox in the county.

Just an FYI, my grey fox diet "theory" is backed up by my Bachelor of Science degree in wildlife biology. Knowledge that earns me a comfortable living with the New York State dept of Environmental Conservation.

From your own post:

"when close to the location where we were headed, he scanned a field with the handheld spot."

So....you drive around with a spotlight looking for fox in the fields, then pull over and call them?

It's pretty obvious why you see no grey fox. BTW, it's illegal to use a light from the vehicle with a gun on board in NY.

You are obviously of ill conscience to become so bitter at the mere mention of killing a grey fox in your area. Not sure why but I can assure you, I am not the only one that regularly harvests grey fox in wyoming county, and you are not the only one that road-hunts.

In your hyperbolic attempt to discredit me, your profound lack of knowledge of grey fox (and probably red fox as well) shines brightly. I'm sorry you're inept at things you wish you knew more about but the solution is to have an open mind and consider the possibility that somebody might know more than you about a particular subject, not insult them.

I learn something every single day, and I'm glad there are people that know things I don't. I like to learn. My (arguably) comprehensive knowledge of the North American foxes comes from my love of the sport and my training. Yes, I do read alot of books, many of which were required reading in college. Examining fecal matter is a rock solid way of learning mammal behavior, taught by every professor of biology in every accredited university in the world. I can understand why you joke about it since you obviously have no interest in learning beyond the "facts" your drive-by hunting has taught you.

I have been trying to learn to kill coyotes for the last 15 yrs. I came here initially to soak up any information I could about the subject. I'm a very avid fox hunter with literally hundreds of kills. I have killed around 10 or 12 coyotes in the last 15 yrs or so. They do not respond to a call the same as a fox. Most information available is about western coyotes. Western and eastern coyotes are 2 completely different sub-species of Canis latrans. I know you only care about what the spotlight tells you but I was explaining my purpose. I know some very good coyote callers from your area but of course, hunters guard their secrets closely.(I'm sure that's a lie anyway, right?) I will continue to soak up every bit of knowledge I can on this subject and others, unlike you....sadly.

Sadly, I made a mistake by posting in your thread. I have made mistakes before. I will not make this one again.

Best of luck to you in life and in your red fox hunting. Always remember to bring a camera and photo every "trophy" that you kill, so that you can prove it to people. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/ooo.gif

I apologize to everybody for the tone this conversation has taken. I will not be posting any more in this thread.
 
Pardon my last post, as flaming doesn't serve the general good on here. And if anyone was offended, I apologize deeply.

Rather than continue a combative string within this post, I decided to go and do a little research, and, if so, be more than willing to accept that I was wrong if any research turned out that I was.
Since I respect a person who has achieved in life, and reading hickerx2's last post, sustaining a BS degree in Fish and Wildlife Biology, and being employed by DEC as a biologist for 11 yrs., it is no small feat. If hickerx2 has that amount of education, coupled with a good long time of hunting experience, then I gotta take my hat off to him.

Based on the "Outdoor Life Series" that I have in my small humble library, I have a few of the old "How to" books that I bought and read many years ago. Remembering the volume "How to Track and Find Game" by Clyde Ormond, I decided to pull it and read specifically on the Grey Fox.

These are exact excerpts from that book that pertain to the differences stated here;

"His (gray fox) general distribution cover's approximately half of the area of that of the red fox, with the ranges of the two species overlapping in many regions. The gray fox is most commonly found east of the Mississippi in the Northeast.
The tracks of the gray fox resemble that of the red fox, except that they are a trifle smaller. Another slight difference is that the imprints left by the toe pads of the gray fox are somewhat larger than those left by the red fox, despite the lesser size of the imprint as a whole.

In general, the methods of locating the gray species are the same as used in finding red foxes. Both foxes are found by searching those areas which they habitually frequent; by coming upon them incidentally while in pursuit of other game or another outdoor activity; by the use of hunting hounds trained for the purpose; and, recently, by the art of varmint calling.

Both species will come to the offal left by game kills, and to carrion.

In brushy country especially, the gray fox is susceptible to varmint calling. The same technique as that used for the red foxes is employed, and night calling is often productive. For this, one should choose a windless night, when sounds carry far. More over, the technique works better in open areas, devoid of large trees. Of course, areas of known rodent populations and other fox foods such as juniper berries are apt to yield better results.

The technique involves two or more hunters working together. First they drive, as noiselessly as possible, into the chosen area after dark, walking the last lap where necessary. Once there, the hunters get settled, generally low to the ground and sitting comfortably.
Once the calling begins, there should be no further noise or movement. The caller begins with the loud, weird cry of a rabbit that has been caught. This call is repeated in sequences in the manner of a real rabbit.


Other points were;

-The gray fox can climb trees to check hunting areas or to escape enemies (as I mentioned).

Also, regarding scat sign;

-Often found along road edges or trails, scat of the gray fox is sharply tapered and usually contains feathers or the fur of small mammals. Since the gray fox eats more berries than the red, the grays scat is usually darker......and I might add, slightly smaller in size.


These were selections taken from the short descriptive section based on the gray fox directly by Ormond, but they encompass a large part of the (smallish) chapter.

Based on what this narrative of the gray fox indicates, and aside from your education or position, I feel that you're incorrect in your belief's, or understanding of the species hicker.


Bob
 
hicker,

Quote:
A pic of a red fox is proof of what?

Wild claims?



No, it's a response to this comment you made;

Quote:
It sounds like Handgunr is pretty good at hunting red fox. I guess I could be closed-minded as well and say that there's no way that red fox respond as eagerly as he claims( here, in the last 15 yrs or so, they respond very cautiously, often circling downwind), but then I'd be like you guys....so I won't say it.



I posted a photo, like you mentioned you had, to prove your gray fox take.


Also,
Quote:
My "wild claim" was that there are grey fox in Wyoming county.....which you immediately disputed based upon your intimate knowledge of foxes.



There you go again.....
No you're claim was that you took as many grays in this area as you did, and mentioned that it was "odd to do any amount of calling and not see one" based on my statement.

I never said there were no grays in Wyoming Co., never called you a liar, and basically told you that "I DON'T SEE" the gray fox that you were claiming to take. And that's a fact.

You need to re-read the posts as now you're making no sense.

Also, don't even try to educate me on hunting, I'll produce results I can prove, not claims I can't back up.....

...again, if you read the post thoroughly (before slamming it) you'll see where we were heading from one hunting area to another. We don't road hunt, but we will keep our eyes open for sign, or fox, heading from one area to another. Many times it uncovers new areas TO HUNT. Tell me you haven't done it.


Quote:
BTW, it's illegal to use a light from the vehicle with a gun on board in NY.



Again....you're wrong, or at least you purposely omitted the whole law to support that statement.

As far as law is concerned, even Environmental Conservation Law, stick with what they hired you for, Wildlife Biology, not ENCON Enforcement.
I spent far more years as a Police Firearms Instructor alone, than you have doing what you're doing now, not to mention the total years enforcing law, so don't even try to compete. That includes instructing police college courses as well, if that impresses you.

The specific law you quoted states that;

You may use lights to observe deer and bear (as well as other types of game, "look at furbearer hunting") under the following conditions;

-You are not within 500ft. of a home or farm building, unless you have permission from the owner or lessee.

-While in or on a motor vehicle and operating a light and no person has a firearm or bow (here it comes) UNLESS;
....the firearm is taken down or the bow is unstrung.
....the firearm is securely fastened in a case, or;
....the firearm is locked in the trunk of the vehicle, or;
....the firearm is a handgun.....

Our guns are cased, AND taken down, AND in an inaccessible part of the vehicle, meaning "out of arms length".

Rather than jeopardize the thread I'm gonna bail here, as this is getting nowhere, and at a risk of the thread being closed because of a foolish dispute, it would be a waste to others.

Bob
 
Good read fellas. Lots of very useful information contained within that string of dialog. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/bowingsmilie.gif

Funny thing is there are exceptions to just about every rule or notion we (more likely I) have when it comes to the critters we chase. And chase is the operative word for me. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/confused1.gif

I don't have a degree in biology, I haven't harvested a ton of predators so my obervations, logically, wouldn't carry the same weight as those previously made. I'll say this though, most of the stuff (if not all) about fox biology given makes sense to me. I've seen a grey fox in a tree, I've seen them in the same areas as red fox, I've seen then in fields and I've seen reds in the deep woods. Maybe someday I'll be kwolwdgable enough to closely examine their individual turds and know what species left it behind.

While the "discussion" seemed to be heating up, it is refreshing to see that you two gentlemen took a road higher than many others would have.

I don't know either gent personally, but I sincerely hope that both will continue to share their knowledge.

Oh, would you believe me if I told you I've shot woodchucks out of trees (twice) and that I've seen them out at night???
/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/shocked.gif

Good Hunting,

Perri
 
Knockem', Perri and Clutch

Great comic relief /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/grinning-smiley-003.gif /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/grinning-smiley-003.gif /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/laugh.gif /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/laugh.gif /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/laugh.gif /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/laugh.gif


Oh, by the way (Mark) Dennis scored tonight right at dusk on a beauty red fox up on Carlton Hill State Lands. Got him with the magic bullet call.
I guess his pelt is so nice that Dennis is gonna tan him out and make a wall hanging out of him.

We're gonna head up tomorrow late afternoon to see if we can duplicate tonights hunt.
He said the walking was really tough and covering 40yds was like walking on "bowling balls". Lots of hard ice on the plowed fields.

Take care,
Bob
 
Looks like a good day for gettin out. The fluffy stuff is coming down slow in the S. Southern tier, but good tracking white stuff.

Bob, give Dennis my congrats. Love to see that pelt of his. We didn't get the ice down here, nor the amount of snow you did so the conditions are pretty good. Best on todays hunt /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/grinning-smiley-003.gif Regards to all, Mark.
 
Thanks Mark...

I'll pass the kudos on to Dennis. I'll see if I can get a shot of the hide before he starts soaking it.

I don't have the ice coating down here in the southern part of the county like they do up on the north end. It's a higher elevation for sure, but when we hunted it the night before last, it was loud and very difficult walking.
Where Dennis hunted last night was even worse because of having to course the plowed fields.
Currently, were getting hit with blowing snow off of Lake Erie, even though were inland quite a bit.

It's suppose to subside, and then return later in the day. Snow's not a problem, but wind can be a pain when calling.

Talk to you later......
Bob
 
Hey guys,

Time to hunt. I'm going to test those theories on the coyotes being hungry before a snow storm. At least on a stand or two.

Hope the they're hungry!!!
 
Back
Top